❓ A parliamentary question regarding the Department of Fisheries' advice to Mr. Palmer and the Minister's decision to appeal to the High Court. The Minister acknowledges the complexity of the case and states that he is seeking legal advice.
AnsweredQoN 372Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
I refer to the editorial in The West Australian on 12 November outlining the Department of Fisheries’ role in advising Mr Palmer on the regulations for fishing near Carnarvon. If the editorial is true, why has the minister not accepted that an error was made by the department and withdrawn the appeal to the High Court? Hon KIM CHANCE
AnswerView source ↗
Was notice given of that question? Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon KIM CHANCE replied : Was notice given of that question? Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Was notice given of that question? Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon KIM CHANCE replied : Was notice given of that question? Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Was notice given of that question? Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon Murray Criddle: No. The editorial is in the public domain. Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon KIM CHANCE: It certainly is. Part of the case referred to by the honourable member as in the public domain relates to an application to the High Court, which, I believe, makes the whole matter sub judice. That would make it improper - Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon Peter Foss: Only to discuss the case. Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon Murray Criddle: It is referred to in the editorial. Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Hon KIM CHANCE: Yes. The Palmer case is an extremely difficult one. I have spoken to a number of members of the Opposition privately about this case. I have a view on it. Recently, although some time before the editorial referred to by the member was published, I sought legal advice about the propriety involved in the event that I gave a direction to the Executive Director of the Department of Fisheries to withdraw the High Court application. I have recently received that advice and, with the Attorney General and the Premier, I will consider that advice. However, we have not yet resolved the matter and I hope we will be able to do so quite soon.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.