❓ A WA parliamentary question seeks details about the Minister for Agriculture and Food's North American trip concerning genetically modified organisms (GMOs), including meetings, concerns raised, and potential gifts received from related companies.
AnsweredQoN 807Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
Minister for Agriculture and Food — NORTH AMERICAN VISIT
I refer to the minister’s recent visit to North America to learn more about the impact of genetically modified organisms in agriculture. (1) Will the minister please table a list of people whom he met with and their occupations during his fact-finding mission? (2) Can the minister please list the organic farmers he met, if any? (3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE
I refer to the minister’s recent visit to North America to learn more about the impact of genetically modified organisms in agriculture. (1) Will the minister please table a list of people whom he met with and their occupations during his fact-finding mission? (2) Can the minister please list the organic farmers he met, if any? (3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE
AnswerView source ↗
On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(1) Will the minister please table a list of people whom he met with and their occupations during his fact-finding mission? (2) Can the minister please list the organic farmers he met, if any? (3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(2) Can the minister please list the organic farmers he met, if any? (3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(4) No.
(1) Will the minister please table a list of people whom he met with and their occupations during his fact-finding mission? (2) Can the minister please list the organic farmers he met, if any? (3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(2) Can the minister please list the organic farmers he met, if any? (3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(3) What were the concerns of these farmers, if any? (4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(4) Did the minister receive any gifts or free services from Monsanto or any other GM companies, farmers, scientists or other specialists? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
On behalf of the Minister for Child Protection, I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(1) On his recent trip to North America, the minister met with approximately 90 people. This included government and industry organisation representatives, as well as university academics and private companies. A detailed list will be provided in the minister’s travel report. (2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(2) The minister did not meet any organic growers. However, he met a number of non-GM growers, including Harry Cope and Rusty Lee from Missouri, and spoke with non-GM grower Garnet Martin from Saskatoon, among others. He also discussed organic and non-GM issues with industry representative groups such as the American Farm Bureau and US Wheat Associates; government officials, including the Saskatchewan agriculture minister and the Canadian opposition spokesman; and grain consultant Marlene Boersch. He left a number of messages by phone with the vice-president of the National Farmers Union in Canada to discuss the organic grower issue, but he was unavailable and did not return his calls. (3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(3) None of the non-GM farmers indicated a concern about the safety of GM crops, and all were comfortable with the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. Concerns were raised about the cost of GM seed and the nature of contracts with seed suppliers. Harry Cope also voiced concern about the development of glyphosate weeds on his farm. (4) No.
(4) No.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.