❓ A WA parliamentary question on notice addresses the State Government's debt to the City of Melville under the Heathcote coordination agreement, payments made, outstanding amounts, and plans to clear the obligation, including offsetting with the valuation of Canning House.
AnsweredQoN 439Legislative Assembly
QuestionView source ↗
(1) Has the State Government paid any of the debt owed to the City of Melville under the requirements of the Heathcote coordination agreement of 2001? (2) If yes, what amounts have been paid? (3) When were the payments made? (4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN
AnswerView source ↗
(1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(2) If yes, what amounts have been paid? (3) When were the payments made? (4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(3) When were the payments made? (4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(2) If yes, what amounts have been paid? (3) When were the payments made? (4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(3) When were the payments made? (4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(4) What parcels of land did they involve? (5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(5) What amount is still owing under the agreement and why has this amount not been cleared as per the agreement? (6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(6) How does the Government plan to clear its obligation to the City of Melville? Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
Ms A.J. MacTIERNAN replied: (1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
(1)-(6) Yes, we have paid some $1.8 million to the City of Melville from the sale of crown land reserves between March 2001 and June 2004. I have the reserve numbers but I will not read them out. The properties include: Marmion Street, Myaree; Potts Street, Melville; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4700 Sullivan Way, Kardinya; lot 4681 Fielder Court, Kardinya; The Esplanade, Mount Pleasant; lot 4701 Maritime Avenue, Kardinya; Marmion Street, Melville; lot 4702 Ellis Road, Kardinya; lot 102 Burke Drive, Attadale; lot 101 Page Street, Attadale; and lot 15078 Burke Drive, Attadale. The sum remaining for the City of Melville is some $4.132 million. Negotiations are under way with the City of Melville on the valuation of Canning House. Members will perhaps not be aware that we can offset the balance outstanding by the valuation of Canning House. Our preliminary advice is that Canning House and the surrounding property will be valued in excess of $4 million. Hence, the State will hopefully not have any liability to the City of Melville. That means that the very foolish action on the part of the member for Alfred Cove in leading the charge to block the excision of the four houses on Wireless Hill will leave the City of Melville some $2 million in the red. It will also, of course, leave a series of four heritage houses unrenovated and the City of Melville with no resources for the restoration of those properties - a lose-lose result for the member for Alfred Cove!
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.