❓ Question regarding the Minister's intended action concerning the remaining members of the Finance Brokers Supervisory Board. The exchange devolves into personal attacks and a point of order from the Speaker.
AnsweredQoN 132Legislative Assembly
QuestionView source ↗
As a supplementary question, what action does the minister intend to take in relation to the other three members of the Finance Brokers Supervisory Board? Mr SHAVE
AnswerView source ↗
Those people will be given the opportunity to respond - Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Mr SHAVE replied: Those people will be given the opportunity to respond - Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Those people will be given the opportunity to respond - Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
[See paper No 209.]
Mr SHAVE replied: Those people will be given the opportunity to respond - Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Those people will be given the opportunity to respond - Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Dr Gallop: They have; they say they are staying, which is not very good, of course. Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Mr SHAVE: The Leader of the Opposition can be as sarcastic as he likes. To the best of my knowledge, not all of the members have yet replied to my request on this matter. Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Dr Gallop: The minister blames everyone else and accepts no responsibility. He is a man without honour and the rest of his colleagues look upon him as a liability. The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
The SPEAKER: Order! I have allowed a lot of interjections. I try to allow the person who has asked the question - that is, the Leader of the Opposition - to pursue the matter. That does not mean continual harassment of the minister. Perhaps the minister will finish his answer, otherwise I may have to stand again within 10 seconds. Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
Mr SHAVE: I table an extract from the Hansard of 25 August 1992, which highlights the Leader of the Opposition’s comments in relation to honour. [See paper No 209.]
[See paper No 209.]
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.