A WA parliamentary question on notice regarding the government's purchase of land from Mr. and Mrs. Milne, focusing on the timeline, reasons for delays, and the urgency of the matter due to their financial and health situation.

AnsweredQoN 490Legislative Assembly
Asked
8 November 2005
Portfolio
State Development

QuestionView source ↗

(1) When did Landcorp first contact Mr Albert Milne and Mrs Angela Milne of Lot 123 Old Coast Road, Binningup, concerning the Government purchase of their land?
(2) How many times have Landcorp contacted Mr and Mrs Milne since the year 2000?
(3) Why has the Government not ascertained that due to financial and health reasons an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne was necessary?
(4) When did the Minister for State Development first receive advice and recommendations from the Department of Industry and Resource?
(5) What was the length of time taken for the Department of Industry and Resources to make their recommendations to the Minister?
(6) What reasons can be given for the length of time taken for the Minister to address Mr and Mrs Milne’s situation?
(7) Having provided reasons for an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne, why has Cabinet not dealt with this issue as a matter of urgency?
(8) On what date will the Minister approve and enable the Department of Industry and Resources to make an offer of sale to Mr and Mrs Milne?
(9) Dependent upon an offer being made at some future date, will the Minister guarantee that negotiations, if required, will commence immediately after the initial offer with a view to finalising this matter?

AnswerView source ↗

Answered
1 December 2005
Responded by
Minister for State Development
Response time
23 days
I am advised that: 1) On 30 March 2000 LandCorp spoke to Mrs Angela Milne for the first time by telephone. Government had recently approved the expansion and first round budget allocation for acquisitions at Kemerton and a letter was sent by the then Department of Resources Development (DRD) to all affected landowners. This letter offered landowners the opportunity of meeting with LandCorp and DRD officers if they wished to discuss their situation and this was what prompted Mrs Milne to contact Land Corp. (2) LandCorp's file records indicate that the Milnes' have been contacted approximately twenty times since 2000. (3) The Government has ascertained that due to financial and health reasons an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne is necessary. Negotiations to purchase the Milnes' land, improvements and business (with no lease back) commenced in November 2005 following Cabinet Approval of the hardship case. (4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
1) On 30 March 2000 LandCorp spoke to Mrs Angela Milne for the first time by telephone. Government had recently approved the expansion and first round budget allocation for acquisitions at Kemerton and a letter was sent by the then Department of Resources Development (DRD) to all affected landowners. This letter offered landowners the opportunity of meeting with LandCorp and DRD officers if they wished to discuss their situation and this was what prompted Mrs Milne to contact Land Corp. (2) LandCorp's file records indicate that the Milnes' have been contacted approximately twenty times since 2000. (3) The Government has ascertained that due to financial and health reasons an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne is necessary. Negotiations to purchase the Milnes' land, improvements and business (with no lease back) commenced in November 2005 following Cabinet Approval of the hardship case. (4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
1) On 30 March 2000 LandCorp spoke to Mrs Angela Milne for the first time by telephone. Government had recently approved the expansion and first round budget allocation for acquisitions at Kemerton and a letter was sent by the then Department of Resources Development (DRD) to all affected landowners. This letter offered landowners the opportunity of meeting with LandCorp and DRD officers if they wished to discuss their situation and this was what prompted Mrs Milne to contact Land Corp. (2) LandCorp's file records indicate that the Milnes' have been contacted approximately twenty times since 2000. (3) The Government has ascertained that due to financial and health reasons an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne is necessary. Negotiations to purchase the Milnes' land, improvements and business (with no lease back) commenced in November 2005 following Cabinet Approval of the hardship case. (4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(2) LandCorp's file records indicate that the Milnes' have been contacted approximately twenty times since 2000. (3) The Government has ascertained that due to financial and health reasons an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne is necessary. Negotiations to purchase the Milnes' land, improvements and business (with no lease back) commenced in November 2005 following Cabinet Approval of the hardship case. (4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(3) The Government has ascertained that due to financial and health reasons an urgent response to Mr and Mrs Milne is necessary. Negotiations to purchase the Milnes' land, improvements and business (with no lease back) commenced in November 2005 following Cabinet Approval of the hardship case. (4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
Negotiations to purchase the Milnes' land, improvements and business (with no lease back) commenced in November 2005 following Cabinet Approval of the hardship case. (4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(4) In July 2004 DoIR advised the then Minister for State Development that a proposed hardship case was being prepared in respect of the Milne's. There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
There followed a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(5) Once the Milnes' wishes were confirmed in August 2005 (that they wanted the Government to purchase their land, improvements and business) it took DoIR approximately four weeks to complete the Cabinet Submission and forward it to the Minister. (6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(6) The relatively short length of time taken to address this matter (given its complexity and the varying scenarios put forward by the Milnes') is due to the fact that the Minister considered it to be important. Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
Prior to this was a process of obtaining present and future valuations for the land, improvements and business, articulating and evaluating alternative purchase scenarios suggested by the Milnes', and exploring with the Department of Treasury and Finance that department's definition of hardship in relation to the various scenarios being considered. (7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(7) The matter has been dealt with expeditiously in the circumstances. (8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(8) None. LandCorp will make an offer of purchase, not sale. It commenced negotiations with the Milnes' agent in the week beginning 6 November 2005. (9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.
(9) The offer will be made and negotiations (if necessary) conducted by LandCorp, an agency for which I am not responsible.

Explore WA Government Data

Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.

Explore more