Hon Robin Chapple questions the Minister for State Development regarding mineral tenement applications within Karijini National Park, alleging contravention of government policy and potential misleading of Parliament.

AnsweredQoN 2164Legislative Council
Asked
1 July 2004
Portfolio
State Development

QuestionView source ↗

With regard to question on notice No. 1990 asked by Hon Giz Watson, MLC on Thursday, May 6 and answered on June 22 2004, I ask -
(1) Was it the Minister’s advice and understanding that at the time of answering that question, no mineral tenements had been applied over National Parks or nature reserves?
(2) Is the Minister aware that in the Karijini National Park, exploration leases have been applied for under Section 58(1)(b) of the
Mining Act 1978,
and are currently being processed in contravention to Government policy, these being -
(a) E47/1249 - applied April 17 2003 - Maincoast Pty Ltd;
(b) E47/1336 - applied November 25 2003 - Range Resources Limited;
(c) E47/1360 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(d) E47/1362 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(e) E47/1363 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(f) E47/1364 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group;
(n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd;
(o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd;
(p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and
(q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(3) If yes to (2), did the Minister or his Department mislead Parliament?
(4) If yes to (2), at what point in the process will the responsible Minister inform these respective exploration companies that their tenements will not be granted?

AnswerView source ↗

Answered
2 July 2004
Responded by
Parliamentary Secretary representing the Minister for State Development
Response time
1 days
(b) E47/1336 - applied November 25 2003 - Range Resources Limited; (c) E47/1360 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (d) E47/1362 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (e) E47/1363 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (f) E47/1364 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(c) E47/1360 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (d) E47/1362 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (e) E47/1363 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (f) E47/1364 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(d) E47/1362 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (e) E47/1363 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (f) E47/1364 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(e) E47/1363 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (f) E47/1364 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(f) E47/1364 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(g) E47/1365 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(h) E47/1366 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(i) E47/1367 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(j) E47/1368 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(k) E47/1369 - applied January 28 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(l) E47/1421 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(m) E47/1419 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; (n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(n) E47/1288 - applied August 11 2003 - Fox Resources Ltd; (o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(o) E47/1430 - applied June 16 2004 - D.F.D. Rhodes Pty Ltd; (p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(p) E47/1422 - applied May 31 2004 - Fortescue Metals Group; and (q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
(q) E47/1412 - applied May 24 2004 - Rangal Coal Pty Ltd?
I am advised: (1) I suggest that the Hon. Member re-examine the answer given by the Minister on 22 June 2004 to see it does not prevent applications for exploration licences being received. (2) The licences have been applied for and the policy will apply. (3) Question on Notice number 1990 sought advice on whether mining leases and exploration licences in native reserves and national parks has been granted. The question the Hon. Member now asks relates to applications for mining leases and exploration licences. There is a distinct difference between the application and a grant of a mining lease and exploration licence. (4) Once the procedures in the Mining Act have been followed.
(1) I suggest that the Hon. Member re-examine the answer given by the Minister on 22 June 2004 to see it does not prevent applications for exploration licences being received. (2) The licences have been applied for and the policy will apply. (3) Question on Notice number 1990 sought advice on whether mining leases and exploration licences in native reserves and national parks has been granted. The question the Hon. Member now asks relates to applications for mining leases and exploration licences. There is a distinct difference between the application and a grant of a mining lease and exploration licence. (4) Once the procedures in the Mining Act have been followed.
(2) The licences have been applied for and the policy will apply. (3) Question on Notice number 1990 sought advice on whether mining leases and exploration licences in native reserves and national parks has been granted. The question the Hon. Member now asks relates to applications for mining leases and exploration licences. There is a distinct difference between the application and a grant of a mining lease and exploration licence. (4) Once the procedures in the Mining Act have been followed.
(3) Question on Notice number 1990 sought advice on whether mining leases and exploration licences in native reserves and national parks has been granted. The question the Hon. Member now asks relates to applications for mining leases and exploration licences. There is a distinct difference between the application and a grant of a mining lease and exploration licence. (4) Once the procedures in the Mining Act have been followed.
(4) Once the procedures in the Mining Act have been followed.

Explore WA Government Data

Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.

Explore more