❓ A parliamentary question addresses environmental concerns regarding a proposed limestone quarry near Lake Nowergup, focusing on environmental aspects, ministerial call-in powers, and alternative quarry locations. The Minister's response outlines environmental protections already in place and justifies the quarry's location due to resource needs.
AnsweredQoN 932Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
LAKE NOWERGUP VICINITY — LIMESTONE QUARRY
I refer to proposals to develop a limestone quarry close to Lake Nowergup. (1) The minister was quoted in media reports as stating he would ensure that environmental aspects were taken into account. What are the environmental aspects to which the minister referred? (2) What call-in powers are available to the minister to stop the quarry? (3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY
I refer to proposals to develop a limestone quarry close to Lake Nowergup. (1) The minister was quoted in media reports as stating he would ensure that environmental aspects were taken into account. What are the environmental aspects to which the minister referred? (2) What call-in powers are available to the minister to stop the quarry? (3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY
AnswerView source ↗
I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(1) The minister was quoted in media reports as stating he would ensure that environmental aspects were taken into account. What are the environmental aspects to which the minister referred? (2) What call-in powers are available to the minister to stop the quarry? (3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(2) What call-in powers are available to the minister to stop the quarry? (3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(1) The minister was quoted in media reports as stating he would ensure that environmental aspects were taken into account. What are the environmental aspects to which the minister referred? (2) What call-in powers are available to the minister to stop the quarry? (3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(2) What call-in powers are available to the minister to stop the quarry? (3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(3) Is the minister aware of other more suitable locations for limestone quarrying in the vicinity? Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
Hon ROBYN McSWEENEY replied: I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
I thank the honourable member for some notice of the question. (1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(1) The Minister for Environment determined appeals in relation to the Environmental Protection Authority’s decision not to assess the proposal on 30 March 2010—reference 299-300 of 2009. These decisions were made on the understanding that other provisions under the act will apply in the future, including requirements for works approvals, licences and clearing permits. The Western Australian Planning Commission’s conditional approval to a development application—reference 30-50215-1—for extractive industry on the subject land on 26 October 2010 also addressed environmental aspects, including that excavation and rehabilitation is to be done in accordance with the approved excavation and rehabilitation management plan, and the determination and protection of buffer areas is to be based on Department of Environment and Conservation advice. (2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(2) The proposal is currently being considered by the State Administrative Tribunal, which is well placed to deal with this matter. (3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
(3) The proposed extractive industry is within a priority resource area identified by state planning policy 2.4, basic raw materials. The minister is advised that the geological stratas that contain basic raw materials in the metropolitan area run north to south along the Perth coastal plain, with lime sand closest to the coast, and there is a strata of limestone, including the subject Wanneroo limestone area, and, to the east, a sand strata. The Wanneroo limestone resource has provided the limestone material for the current development of the northern suburbs and is critical to the future northern growth. The next northern significant limestone resource occurs in Yanchep National Park. To the south, development has sterilised limestone resources until south of Fremantle, which highlights the critical nature of this area as an important metropolitan limestone resource.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.