❓ Hon. Edwardes requests the Premier table credit card invoices for transparency. The Premier declines due to resource constraints but offers to investigate specific concerns.
AnsweredQoN 1662Legislative Assembly
Asked
17 June 2003
Member
Portfolio
Premier; Minister for Public Sector Management; Federal Affairs; Science; Citizenship and Multicultural Interests
QuestionView source ↗
(b) in the interest of open, accountable and transparent Government, will the Premier table copies of the invoices for each card for the past six months?
The latest internal audit of expenditure for the Department was completed on 17 June 2003. The testing indicated that there were adequate controls in place over the Department’s credit card expenditure. External review of departmental transactions, including credit card expenditure, is also undertaken by the Office of the Auditor General as part of that Office’s audit cycle. It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit. (b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
External review of departmental transactions, including credit card expenditure, is also undertaken by the Office of the Auditor General as part of that Office’s audit cycle. It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit. (b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit. (b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
(b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
The latest internal audit of expenditure for the Department was completed on 17 June 2003. The testing indicated that there were adequate controls in place over the Department’s credit card expenditure. External review of departmental transactions, including credit card expenditure, is also undertaken by the Office of the Auditor General as part of that Office’s audit cycle. It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit. (b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
External review of departmental transactions, including credit card expenditure, is also undertaken by the Office of the Auditor General as part of that Office’s audit cycle. It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit. (b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit. (b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
(b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
AnswerView source ↗
Answered
13 August 2003
Response time
57 days
(a) All expenditure, including that by credit card, is subject to regular periodic testing under the Department of the Premier and Cabinet’s internal audit program in accordance with Part XII of the Treasurer’s Instructions accompanying the
Financial Administration and Audit Act 1985.
The latest internal audit of expenditure for the Department was completed on 17 June 2003. The testing indicated that there were adequate controls in place over the Department’s credit card expenditure.
External review of departmental transactions, including credit card expenditure, is also undertaken by the Office of the Auditor General as part of that Office’s audit cycle.
It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit.
(b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
Financial Administration and Audit Act 1985.
The latest internal audit of expenditure for the Department was completed on 17 June 2003. The testing indicated that there were adequate controls in place over the Department’s credit card expenditure.
External review of departmental transactions, including credit card expenditure, is also undertaken by the Office of the Auditor General as part of that Office’s audit cycle.
It would not be possible to ascertain when individual credit card usage was audited without reviewing working papers of both the internal and external audit functions. For example, credit card purchases may be included on a sample basis in transactional testing of expenditure performed by both internal and external audit.
(b) It would be necessary for the Department to devote substantial staff resources to identifying, locating and duplicating thousands of invoices attached to hundreds of credit card statements across all Ministerial offices to comply with this request, I am not prepared to direct the Department to use resources for this purpose but if the Member has a particular concern about usage of a credit card I would be pleased to consider arranging for the Department to provide information on that particular credit card.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.