❓ Hon Robin Chapple questions the Minister for State Development regarding potential discrepancies between departmental advice and answers provided to Parliament in response to previous Questions on Notice (653 and 327). The Minister denies any discrepancies and declines to table or quote briefing notes, stating the answers were self-explanatory.
AnsweredQoN 1385Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
I refer to questions on notice numbers 653 of April 9 2003 and 327 of November 27 2002 and the answers provided -
(1) Does the departmental advice in relation to all the questions asked for number 653 provided to the Minister differ from the answers that have been provided to the Parliament on all of these matters?
(2) If yes to (1), can the Minister quote the specific text of the departmental advice provided to the Minister different from the answer provided by the Minister in the Parliament?
(3) If no to (1), why?
(4) Does the departmental advice in relation to all the questions asked for number 327 provided to the Minister differ from the answers that have been provided to the Parliament on all of these matters?
(5) If yes to (4), can the Minister quote the specific text of the departmental advice provided to the Minister different from the answer provided by the Minister in the Parliament?
(6) If no to (3), why?
(7) Will the Minister table the briefing notes or departmental advice in relation questions on notice numbers 653 and 327 referred to above?
(8) If no to (7), why not?
(9) Will the Minister specifically quote the full text of the briefing notes or departmental advice in relation to questions on notice numbers 653 and 327 referred to above?
(10) If no to (9), why not?
(1) Does the departmental advice in relation to all the questions asked for number 653 provided to the Minister differ from the answers that have been provided to the Parliament on all of these matters?
(2) If yes to (1), can the Minister quote the specific text of the departmental advice provided to the Minister different from the answer provided by the Minister in the Parliament?
(3) If no to (1), why?
(4) Does the departmental advice in relation to all the questions asked for number 327 provided to the Minister differ from the answers that have been provided to the Parliament on all of these matters?
(5) If yes to (4), can the Minister quote the specific text of the departmental advice provided to the Minister different from the answer provided by the Minister in the Parliament?
(6) If no to (3), why?
(7) Will the Minister table the briefing notes or departmental advice in relation questions on notice numbers 653 and 327 referred to above?
(8) If no to (7), why not?
(9) Will the Minister specifically quote the full text of the briefing notes or departmental advice in relation to questions on notice numbers 653 and 327 referred to above?
(10) If no to (9), why not?
AnswerView source ↗
Answered
2 December 2003
Responded by
Parliamentary Secretary representing the Minister for State Development
Response time
39 days
The Minister for State Development emphasises that the answers given to Questions on notice numbers 653 of April 9 2003 and 327 of November 27 2002 did not differ from the Departmental advice provided, as follows: (1) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (2) N/A. (3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(1) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (2) N/A. (3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(2) N/A. (3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(10) N/A.
(1) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (2) N/A. (3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(2) N/A. (3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(3) N/A. (4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(4) It is unclear what the Hon Member believes is different about the advice. (5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(5) N/A. (6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(6) N/A. (7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(7) No. (8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(8) There are none, the answers are self explanatory. (9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(9) N/A. (10) N/A.
(10) N/A.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.