❓ A parliamentary question regarding the 2010 Genetically Modified Audit Program report, specifically concerning GM canola cultivation, compliance, and audit procedures. The Minister's response clarifies the voluntary and compulsory aspects of GM canola cultivation and the audit process.
AnsweredQoN 4203Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
I refer to the 2010 Genetically Modified Audit Program report, and ask -
(1) Were trucks transporting GM canola in the 2010 season required to be sealed as in the 2009 trials?
(2) Figure 1 in the report identifies the key steps in the commercial cultivation of GM canola in 2010. For each of the following steps would the Minister advise which are voluntary and which are compulsory -
(a) inform neighbours;
(b) receive and store seed on-farm in original packaging away from other canola seed;
(c) establish and maintain records of all management practices and deliveries;
(d) sow using clean equipment;
(e) observe buffer zone requirements;
(f) retain empty seed bag labels;
(g) advise CBH of GM variety planted and estimated yield;
(h) inspect and report herbicide efficacy;
(i) apply required plant and equipment hygiene at harvest of GM canola; and
(j) monitor and destroy any GM volunteer plants germinating on farm including paddock, clean down areas or storage areas and spillages?
(3) For each of those steps identified as compulsory in (2), what are the penalties associated with failing to complete this step?
(4) Were audits solely interview based or did auditors inspect farms and verify what farmers told them?
(5) Were interviews conducted with the GM grower themselves?
(6) Were the audit results verified by interviewing other farm workers or the GM growers’ neighbours?
(7) How did the auditors verify 4.3 ‘GM grain deliveries declared as GM’ and 4.4 ‘Delivery transport equipment sealed to avoid spillage’?
(8) Would the Minister table the audit reports from each farm audit for the 2009 and 2010 audits?
(9) Did DAFWA audit CBH grain handling both at GM and non-GM receival points?
(1) Were trucks transporting GM canola in the 2010 season required to be sealed as in the 2009 trials?
(2) Figure 1 in the report identifies the key steps in the commercial cultivation of GM canola in 2010. For each of the following steps would the Minister advise which are voluntary and which are compulsory -
(a) inform neighbours;
(b) receive and store seed on-farm in original packaging away from other canola seed;
(c) establish and maintain records of all management practices and deliveries;
(d) sow using clean equipment;
(e) observe buffer zone requirements;
(f) retain empty seed bag labels;
(g) advise CBH of GM variety planted and estimated yield;
(h) inspect and report herbicide efficacy;
(i) apply required plant and equipment hygiene at harvest of GM canola; and
(j) monitor and destroy any GM volunteer plants germinating on farm including paddock, clean down areas or storage areas and spillages?
(3) For each of those steps identified as compulsory in (2), what are the penalties associated with failing to complete this step?
(4) Were audits solely interview based or did auditors inspect farms and verify what farmers told them?
(5) Were interviews conducted with the GM grower themselves?
(6) Were the audit results verified by interviewing other farm workers or the GM growers’ neighbours?
(7) How did the auditors verify 4.3 ‘GM grain deliveries declared as GM’ and 4.4 ‘Delivery transport equipment sealed to avoid spillage’?
(8) Would the Minister table the audit reports from each farm audit for the 2009 and 2010 audits?
(9) Did DAFWA audit CBH grain handling both at GM and non-GM receival points?
AnswerView source ↗
Answered
9 August 2011
Responded by
Minister for Child Protection representing the Minister for Agriculture and Food
Response time
75 days
(1) No. In 2010 it was no longer a trial but a commercial crop.
(2) Growers who cultivate GM Roundup Ready canola do so under a "Roundup Ready Grower License and Stewardship Agreement" with Monsanto. For the purposes of the answer to question 2 the "key steps" referred to are identified as "compulsory" or "voluntary" according to whether a step is a mandatory requirement of the agreement or not:
(a) Inform neighbours - voluntary.
(b) Receive and store seed on-farm in original packaging away from other canola seed - compulsory.
(c) Establish and maintain records of all management practices and deliveries - compulsory.
(d) Sow using clean equipment - voluntary.
(e) Observe buffer requirements - compulsory.
(f) Retain empty seed bag labels - compulsory.
(g) Advise CBH of GM variety planted and estimated yield - compulsory.
(h) Inspect and report herbicide efficacy - voluntary.
(i) Apply required plant and equipment hygiene at harvest of GM canola - voluntary
(j) Monitor and destroy any GM volunteer plants germinating on farm including paddock, clean down areas or storage areas and spillages - voluntary.
(3) The License and Stewardship Agreement is a legally binding agreement and legal remedies can be sought in the event of a breach.
(4) The audits involved interviews and inspections of farms.
(5) Yes.
(6) No.
(7) Growers confirmed all information provided to auditors as being correct. Since the end of the 2010-11 season, CBH Group has stated there was effective segregation of non-GM canola from GM canola in the season.
(8) No. The Department of Agriculture and Food WA made a commitment to the audited growers that they would not be identified.
(9) No.
Notice: This document is created or edited using unregistered or evaluation copy of rtLib valid for testing or development purposes only. To use it for productive or any other purposes please register it. You may purchase the license on
http://www.rtlib.com
(2) Growers who cultivate GM Roundup Ready canola do so under a "Roundup Ready Grower License and Stewardship Agreement" with Monsanto. For the purposes of the answer to question 2 the "key steps" referred to are identified as "compulsory" or "voluntary" according to whether a step is a mandatory requirement of the agreement or not:
(a) Inform neighbours - voluntary.
(b) Receive and store seed on-farm in original packaging away from other canola seed - compulsory.
(c) Establish and maintain records of all management practices and deliveries - compulsory.
(d) Sow using clean equipment - voluntary.
(e) Observe buffer requirements - compulsory.
(f) Retain empty seed bag labels - compulsory.
(g) Advise CBH of GM variety planted and estimated yield - compulsory.
(h) Inspect and report herbicide efficacy - voluntary.
(i) Apply required plant and equipment hygiene at harvest of GM canola - voluntary
(j) Monitor and destroy any GM volunteer plants germinating on farm including paddock, clean down areas or storage areas and spillages - voluntary.
(3) The License and Stewardship Agreement is a legally binding agreement and legal remedies can be sought in the event of a breach.
(4) The audits involved interviews and inspections of farms.
(5) Yes.
(6) No.
(7) Growers confirmed all information provided to auditors as being correct. Since the end of the 2010-11 season, CBH Group has stated there was effective segregation of non-GM canola from GM canola in the season.
(8) No. The Department of Agriculture and Food WA made a commitment to the audited growers that they would not be identified.
(9) No.
Notice: This document is created or edited using unregistered or evaluation copy of rtLib valid for testing or development purposes only. To use it for productive or any other purposes please register it. You may purchase the license on
http://www.rtlib.com
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.