❓ Question probes the practice of the Premier's office providing generic answers to parliamentary questions, questioning its impact on ministerial autonomy and transparency. The Minister defends the practice as efficient for whole-of-government responses.
AnsweredQoN 2635Legislative Assembly
Asked
2 March 2004
Member
Portfolio
Police and Emergency Services; Justice; Community Safety
QuestionView source ↗
(b) does the office of Premier and Cabinet supply the Minister with a prepared answer; (c) if the generic response is different to the response prepared by your Ministerial office, what happens to the original answer; (d) are the original answers available on file, through freedom of information; (e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(c) if the generic response is different to the response prepared by your Ministerial office, what happens to the original answer; (d) are the original answers available on file, through freedom of information; (e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(d) are the original answers available on file, through freedom of information; (e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(c) if the generic response is different to the response prepared by your Ministerial office, what happens to the original answer; (d) are the original answers available on file, through freedom of information; (e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(d) are the original answers available on file, through freedom of information; (e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(e) if so, which file and in which office; (f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(f) by the office of Premier and Cabinet supplying generic answers for the Minister to use is it a reflection on the Premier’s trust in the ability of the Minister’s staff to answer questions; and (g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
(g) by using generic answers to questions on notice, supplied by the office of Premier and Cabinet is it a reflection of the Minister’s commitment to free and open Government?
AnswerView source ↗
Answered
3 June 2004
Responded by
Minister for Police and Emergency Services; Justice; Community Safety
Response time
93 days
(a) - (g) There are times when questions require a whole of Government response.
Where these circumstances arise the Department of Premier and Cabinet is best placed to prepare an accurate and timely response, which avoids wasteful duplication of Government resources.
Ultimately all answers are however signed off by myself.
Where these circumstances arise the Department of Premier and Cabinet is best placed to prepare an accurate and timely response, which avoids wasteful duplication of Government resources.
Ultimately all answers are however signed off by myself.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.