❓ A parliamentary question regarding the cleanup of a former uranium mine at Lake Way, questioning the verification process and the presence of radioactive material. The Minister's response addresses the presence of naturally occurring uranium and challenges the questioner's motives.
AnsweredQoN 696Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
URANIUM MINE, LAKE WAY
I refer to question on notice 867 of 11 October 2000 from Hon Giz Watson to the Minister for Mines, and to photographs and data contained on my website entitled “2010-07-10 Lake Way Site.pdf”. (1) What process was used to verify that the uranium had indeed been cleaned up at the former Lake Way uranium site? (2) Can the minister explain why radioactive uranium oxide and ore is still lying around unburied and unfenced at the Lake Way site, when part (4) of question 867 was said to have been complied with? (3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE
I refer to question on notice 867 of 11 October 2000 from Hon Giz Watson to the Minister for Mines, and to photographs and data contained on my website entitled “2010-07-10 Lake Way Site.pdf”. (1) What process was used to verify that the uranium had indeed been cleaned up at the former Lake Way uranium site? (2) Can the minister explain why radioactive uranium oxide and ore is still lying around unburied and unfenced at the Lake Way site, when part (4) of question 867 was said to have been complied with? (3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE
AnswerView source ↗
I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(1) What process was used to verify that the uranium had indeed been cleaned up at the former Lake Way uranium site? (2) Can the minister explain why radioactive uranium oxide and ore is still lying around unburied and unfenced at the Lake Way site, when part (4) of question 867 was said to have been complied with? (3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(2) Can the minister explain why radioactive uranium oxide and ore is still lying around unburied and unfenced at the Lake Way site, when part (4) of question 867 was said to have been complied with? (3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(4)–(5) Not applicable.
(1) What process was used to verify that the uranium had indeed been cleaned up at the former Lake Way uranium site? (2) Can the minister explain why radioactive uranium oxide and ore is still lying around unburied and unfenced at the Lake Way site, when part (4) of question 867 was said to have been complied with? (3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(2) Can the minister explain why radioactive uranium oxide and ore is still lying around unburied and unfenced at the Lake Way site, when part (4) of question 867 was said to have been complied with? (3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(3) Is it correct that the material identified on the website is associated with a number of old mining slots viewable on Google Maps and Earth? (4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(4) What action will the minister take to ensure that the area is remediated? (5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(5) What action will the minister take in respect of misleading information from the department and/or the company involved in reporting to him that the area had been remediated? Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
Hon NORMAN MOORE replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
I thank the member for some notice of this question. I indicate that clearly the member is seeking to increase the number of hits on his website by asking a question every day that relates to his website and then requiring someone to look at it. At last count, on this particular one there were three. (1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(1) The Lake Way area was inspected by officers from the Department of Mines and Petroleum on 27 July 2010. The material was confirmed as naturally occurring uranium-bearing rock by subsequent laboratory testing. (2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(2) Background radiation levels vary around the Lake Way area due to the presence of an irregularly shaped uranium ore body that outcrops in places. (3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(3) It is not possible to provide a definitive answer as DMP has not identified the precise material in the photographs supplied on the website. There are a number of known former costean sites in the Lake Way area, but also a number of areas where the ore body naturally outcrops. (4)–(5) Not applicable.
(4)–(5) Not applicable.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.