❓ Opposition asks about conditions of sale for the China Green development in Subiaco, potential disputes, and mediation processes. The Minister does not provide an answer at this time.
AnsweredQoN 691Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
CHINA GREEN, SUBIACO
I understand that there have been some problems in getting information from the minister’s office — The PRESIDENT : Perhaps the member could ask the question he wishes to ask. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I will ask, Mr President, and hopefully we will get an answer. I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA
I understand that there have been some problems in getting information from the minister’s office — The PRESIDENT : Perhaps the member could ask the question he wishes to ask. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I will ask, Mr President, and hopefully we will get an answer. I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA
AnswerView source ↗
I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
The PRESIDENT : Perhaps the member could ask the question he wishes to ask. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I will ask, Mr President, and hopefully we will get an answer. I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I will ask, Mr President, and hopefully we will get an answer. I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
The PRESIDENT : Perhaps the member could ask the question he wishes to ask. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I will ask, Mr President, and hopefully we will get an answer. I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I will ask, Mr President, and hopefully we will get an answer. I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
I refer to the ongoing conflict between the government and the local community over the Subiaco China Green development. (1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(1) Is it true that according to the contract of sale of land from the City of Subiaco to the Subiaco Redevelopment Authority, the city set certain conditions or other parameters, however described, for redevelopment of the China Green precinct? That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
That question is pretty simple, so that cannot have caused the hold-up. It continues — (2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(2) Is the City of Subiaco in dispute with the SRA over the question of the SRA’s compliance with those conditions? That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
That also is a pretty simple question, so that cannot be the reason for the hold-up. The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
The PRESIDENT : Order, Deputy Leader of the Opposition! This is question time; this is not a matter of debating. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : I am just trying to help, Mr President. The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
The PRESIDENT : Deputy Leader of the Opposition, part of the question is already out of order; namely, the use of the words “ongoing conflict”. I invite the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to read the standing orders. I ask the Deputy Leader of the Opposition to please ask his question. Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon SIMON O’BRIEN : Certainly, Mr President. (3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(3) Further to (1) and (2), do the conditions of sale set out a procedure for mediation and determination of any differences between the parties, and has the city initiated that procedure? (4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
(4) Will the minister give an undertaking that she will not grant approval to any amendment of the Subiaco redevelopment scheme until such time as those mediation and determination proceedings are completed? I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
I can see how complex all those yes and no answers must be, Mr President. Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Hon ADELE FARINA replied: I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
I thank the member for some notice of this question. As the member has already been informed by some notice of the answer, I do not have an answer from the minister today and so I am not able to provide it at this time.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.