❓ Mr. Papalia questions Premier Barnett about the impact of state government charges on local government rate increases. Premier Barnett deflects, criticises Papalia's preparation, and offers to investigate the matter further.
AnsweredQoN 427Legislative Assembly
QuestionView source ↗
LOCAL GOVERNMENT RATES — INCREASES
As a supplementary question, with all the pain that the Premier is inflicting on households in Western Australia, why has he not shown enough interest to find out how much of these rate rises is being caused by his government? Mr C.J. BARNETT
As a supplementary question, with all the pain that the Premier is inflicting on households in Western Australia, why has he not shown enough interest to find out how much of these rate rises is being caused by his government? Mr C.J. BARNETT
AnswerView source ↗
Has the member any idea? Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Mr C.J. BARNETT replied: Has the member any idea? Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Has the member any idea? Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Mr C.J. BARNETT replied: Has the member any idea? Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Has the member any idea? Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Mr P. Papalia : I am asking you. You are the Premier. Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Mr C.J. BARNETT : He does not have a clue. One would think that if he were the shadow spokesperson asking questions on electricity prices, he would have actually done a bit of work. I will tell the member what I will do for him; I can do no more. I will inquire of the department, and indeed I will then inquire of the councils to give the member a breakdown tomorrow—if they respond—of what percentage of those rate increases is accounted for by increases in state government charges. Indeed, we might ask them to attribute the rate increase to other expenses that the councils might be incurring, and one of those might be related to their staff numbers.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.