❓ Hon Robin Chapple questions the Minister for Environment regarding the status of the Whim Creek Mine site investigation, particularly in light of recent cyclones and potential discharges. The Minister's response indicates the investigation is ongoing, but the operator is responsible for managing emissions and no discharges were reported after Cyclone Damien.
AnsweredQoN 2893Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
In reference to the Whim Creek Mine site, including discernible features such as Coorinjinna Pool, and acknowledging questions without notice 1070, 936, and 873 and their respective answers, I ask:
(a) has the initial investigation, referred to by the Hon. Minister Dawson in Question Without Notice 936; asked in the Legislative Council on 3 September 2019, been completed:
(i) if yes to (a), would the Minister please provide the findings of the investigation;
(ii) if no to (a), can the Minister advise when this is expected to be completed; and
(iii) if no to (a), have the effects of recent tropical cyclones Damien, Esther, and Ferdinand been considered in the investigation; and
(b) has any sampling or testing been conducted since the tropical storms referred to in (a)(iii):
(i) if yes to (b), could the Minister provide the relevant information; and
(ii) if no to (b), and given the history of the site, does the Department intend to conduct testing at the site:
(A) if yes to (b)(ii), when does the Department expect to have data from the testing?
(B) if no to (b)(ii), why not?
(a) has the initial investigation, referred to by the Hon. Minister Dawson in Question Without Notice 936; asked in the Legislative Council on 3 September 2019, been completed:
(i) if yes to (a), would the Minister please provide the findings of the investigation;
(ii) if no to (a), can the Minister advise when this is expected to be completed; and
(iii) if no to (a), have the effects of recent tropical cyclones Damien, Esther, and Ferdinand been considered in the investigation; and
(b) has any sampling or testing been conducted since the tropical storms referred to in (a)(iii):
(i) if yes to (b), could the Minister provide the relevant information; and
(ii) if no to (b), and given the history of the site, does the Department intend to conduct testing at the site:
(A) if yes to (b)(ii), when does the Department expect to have data from the testing?
(B) if no to (b)(ii), why not?
AnswerView source ↗
Answered
10 June 2020
Responded by
Minister for Environment
Response time
9 days
(i) Not applicable (ii) DWER is not able to provide an expected completion date at this time. (a)(iii)– (b)(B) Whilst the investigation is not complete, the EPN requires that the operator appropriately manages emissions and discharges, including those which may result from cyclones and significant rainfall events. The EPN requires the operators to undertake works and implement management and monitoring plans, including the reporting of all discharges from infrastructure on-site. Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
(ii) DWER is not able to provide an expected completion date at this time. (a)(iii)– (b)(B) Whilst the investigation is not complete, the EPN requires that the operator appropriately manages emissions and discharges, including those which may result from cyclones and significant rainfall events. The EPN requires the operators to undertake works and implement management and monitoring plans, including the reporting of all discharges from infrastructure on-site. Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
(a)(iii)– (b)(B) Whilst the investigation is not complete, the EPN requires that the operator appropriately manages emissions and discharges, including those which may result from cyclones and significant rainfall events. The EPN requires the operators to undertake works and implement management and monitoring plans, including the reporting of all discharges from infrastructure on-site. Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
(ii) DWER is not able to provide an expected completion date at this time. (a)(iii)– (b)(B) Whilst the investigation is not complete, the EPN requires that the operator appropriately manages emissions and discharges, including those which may result from cyclones and significant rainfall events. The EPN requires the operators to undertake works and implement management and monitoring plans, including the reporting of all discharges from infrastructure on-site. Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
(a)(iii)– (b)(B) Whilst the investigation is not complete, the EPN requires that the operator appropriately manages emissions and discharges, including those which may result from cyclones and significant rainfall events. The EPN requires the operators to undertake works and implement management and monitoring plans, including the reporting of all discharges from infrastructure on-site. Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
Following Cyclone Damien, the operators of Whim Creek mine site provided correspondence and photographs to DWER demonstrating that no discharge to the Balla Balla River had occurred. Cyclones Esther and Ferdinand had little impact on the area of Whim Creek. As there have been no discharges, sampling after these storms has not been undertaken by DWER.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.