❓ Dr. Woollard questions the need for an MRI scanner at Fremantle Hospital and the reversal of a previous decision. Mr. Kucera's response indicates conditional approval and attempts to involve private operators.
AnsweredQoN 778Legislative Assembly
QuestionView source ↗
MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING MACHINE, FREMANTLE HOSPITAL
(1) Does Fremantle Hospital need a magnetic resonance imaging scanner? (2) Has it put forward to the Department of Health proposals justifying its case for an MRI scanner? (3) Did the previous state coalition Government approve an MRI scanner installation at Fremantle Hospital irrespective of whether it had a licence to raise revenue; and, if yes, why has the state Labor Government reversed that decision? Mr KUCERA
(1) Does Fremantle Hospital need a magnetic resonance imaging scanner? (2) Has it put forward to the Department of Health proposals justifying its case for an MRI scanner? (3) Did the previous state coalition Government approve an MRI scanner installation at Fremantle Hospital irrespective of whether it had a licence to raise revenue; and, if yes, why has the state Labor Government reversed that decision? Mr KUCERA
AnswerView source ↗
(1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
(2) Has it put forward to the Department of Health proposals justifying its case for an MRI scanner? (3) Did the previous state coalition Government approve an MRI scanner installation at Fremantle Hospital irrespective of whether it had a licence to raise revenue; and, if yes, why has the state Labor Government reversed that decision? Mr KUCERA replied: (1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
(3) Did the previous state coalition Government approve an MRI scanner installation at Fremantle Hospital irrespective of whether it had a licence to raise revenue; and, if yes, why has the state Labor Government reversed that decision? Mr KUCERA replied: (1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr KUCERA replied: (1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
(1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
(2) Has it put forward to the Department of Health proposals justifying its case for an MRI scanner? (3) Did the previous state coalition Government approve an MRI scanner installation at Fremantle Hospital irrespective of whether it had a licence to raise revenue; and, if yes, why has the state Labor Government reversed that decision? Mr KUCERA replied: (1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
(3) Did the previous state coalition Government approve an MRI scanner installation at Fremantle Hospital irrespective of whether it had a licence to raise revenue; and, if yes, why has the state Labor Government reversed that decision? Mr KUCERA replied: (1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr KUCERA replied: (1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
(1)-(3) I answered this question at length yesterday. Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr Board: No, you did not. Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr KUCERA: As I understand it, approval was reliant upon the hospital obtaining a licence, in the same way as it was for Princess Margaret Hospital. Some $2 million is set aside for the purchase of the machine for Fremantle Hospital. Money is also set aside in the budget for the purchase of a machine for Princess Margaret Hospital. These machines have to be run at a legitimate cost. Neither the member for Murdoch nor I mentioned this yesterday, but the Government has approached private operators. Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr Board: Who? The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
The SPEAKER: Member for Murdoch! Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Mr KUCERA: It is to see whether we would be able, through the Fremantle Hospital system, to persuade private operators to relocate to Fremantle Hospital. Because the previous federal Minister for Health and Ageing allowed the majority of machines in this State to be in the private sector, private operators are going like gang busters and making lots of money. If members were in their position, would they relocate into a public hospital? Of course they would not.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.