❓ WA Parliamentary Question on Notice 1955 requests and provides a detailed breakdown of legal advice expenditure by the Department of Planning and Infrastructure, its related agencies, and Main Roads, including provider names, amounts paid, and services rendered between 2000 and 2003.
AnsweredQoN 1955Legislative Assembly
QuestionView source ↗
(b) the name of each provider of legal advice; (c) the amount paid to each provider of legal advice; and (d) the service for which the payments were made?
(c) the amount paid to each provider of legal advice; and (d) the service for which the payments were made?
(d) the service for which the payments were made?
(a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 19/2/01 – 30/6/03 Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 19/2/01 – 30/6/03 Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
19/2/01 – 30/6/03 Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse
Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse
Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse
Watts & Woodhouse
Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
*********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(c) the amount paid to each provider of legal advice; and (d) the service for which the payments were made?
(d) the service for which the payments were made?
(a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 19/2/01 – 30/6/03 Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 19/2/01 – 30/6/03 Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
19/2/01 – 30/6/03 Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health and Safety. Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation TOTAL $1,522,603.80 Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Public Transport Authority ( 1/7/03 – 11/12/03) : (a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) – (d) Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided 1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
1/7/03 – 11/12/03 Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications law, Contract Law advice and Contract Drafting Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court Representation. Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract Drafting Employment/Occupational Health and Safety, Finance/Securities Law. Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court Jaques Representation, Employment/ Occupational Health and Safety Finance/Securities Law. Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law. Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information Technology Law. Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing, Planning, Heritage, Telecommunications Law Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice Crown Solicitor’s Office Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover TOTAL $408,867.54 Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Main Roads (a) – (d): The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business) Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice) Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Minter El lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant) R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd) CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters) Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts) Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects) TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
TOTAL $2 620 577.83 Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Landcorp: The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Question (b) Provider (C )Total Paid (d) Service Provided ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON. $27,679 General Commercial Legal Advice BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON $21,219 General Commercial Legal Advice C ZELESTIS $66,220 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS $672 General Commercial Legal Advice CLAYTON UTZ $223,748 General Commercial Legal Advice COCKS MACNISH $2,148 General Commercial Legal Advice CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH $1,740 General Commercial Legal Advice DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE $29,806 General Commercial Legal Advice EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES $709 General Commercial Legal Advice FREEHILLS LAWYERS $11,976 General Commercial Legal Advice G D CROCKET & CO $2,266 General Commercial Legal Advice GADENS LAWYERS $18,700 General Commercial Legal Advice GILBERT & TOBIN $859 General Commercial Legal Advice HALSEY & ASSOCIATES $1,500 General Commercial Legal Advice HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS $16,469 General Commercial Legal Advice IRDI & ASSOCIATES $2,120 General Commercial Legal Advice JACKSON MCDONALD $16,546 General Commercial Legal Advice J GILMOUR $5,912 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs KOTT GUNNING $45,108 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation M HOWARD $129,617 Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES $230 General Commercial Legal Advice MCLEODS $80,291 General Commercial Legal Advice MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE $371,377 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES $33,021 General Commercial Legal Advice PHILLIPS FOX $173,613 General Commercial Legal Advice PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART $1,151,352 General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON $1,549 General Commercial Legal Advice VALENTI LAWYERS $10,530 General Commercial Legal Advice WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS $9,437 General Commercial Legal Advice Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice $2,456,414 EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
EPRA The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $791,429 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $768,388 Land redevelopment legal issues Allens Arthur Robinson $ 2,496 Commercial land sale settlements Phillip Fox $ 710 Land resumption legal issues Mr R. LeMiere $ 4,200 Legal advice re court actions and claims Lawton Gillon $ 909 Batemans $ 5,281 Godfrey Spowers $ 1,853 Wayne Martin QC $ 636 Considine Griffiths $ 3,260 Wray Associates $ 3,696 SRA (a) $178,808 (b) Provider (c) Amount (d) Service Minter Ellison $168,268 Land redevelopment legal issues Jackson McDonald $ 10,808 Commercial land sale settlements Land resumption legal issues Legal advice re court actions and claims Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Armadale Redevelopment Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $15,141 (b) Watts Woodhouse (c) As Above (d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Midland Redevelopment Authority Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Up until 30 November 2003: (a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $63,653.74 (b) Crown Solicitor’s Office Jackson McDonald Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse (c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20 Jackson McDonald $13,998.50 Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50 (d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing *********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Skea Nelson & Hager Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse
Hager & Partners Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse
Minter Ellison Watts & Woodhouse
Watts & Woodhouse
Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00 Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
Hager & Partners $200.00 Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
Minter Ellison $29,436.54 Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
*********************** Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Albany The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. Name Service Amount Freehills Ordinance Claim 273,801 Lease documents 109,385 Contract documents 9,283 IR advice 322 Environmental advice 1,984 Confidentiality advice 4,285 Hardy Bowen Environmental advice 4,688 Planning advice 1,350 PAA Advice 840 Murray Smith Lease documents 11,203 IR advice 400 Phillips Fox IR advice 4,587 Total 422,128 Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Broome Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $52,409.30 (b) i) Mullins Handcock ii) Phillips Fox iii) Clayton Utz iv) Skea Hager & Co (c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice (d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice Bunbury Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
a. $8,075.00 b. Malcolm McCusker QC Mallesons Stephen Jacques McLeods Young & Young c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000 Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300 McLeods - $1,275 Young & Young - $1,500 d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility McLeods - Application of Act Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport Dampier Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
a) Total Spent: $1,676,542 (b) Provider (c)Amount $ (d) Service Mullins Handcock 119,551 Port Facilities Agreement, leases Wayne S Martin QC 6,682 Port Facilities Agreement Chan Galic Barristers 3,513 Leases Freehill Hollingdale 2,632 Employment Issues Ilbery Barblett 3,000 Port Facilities Agreement Malleson Stephens 1,400 Advice on Directors interest Clayton Utz 1,537,502 Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs Bankwest Conveyancing 2,137 Sale of DPA houses State Revenue Dept 125 Stamping of Agreements Esperance Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $20,541.38 (b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine (ii) Freehills (iii) Blakiston & Crabb (iv) Mullins Handcock (c) (i) $1,266.38 (ii) $17,300 (iii) $125 (iv) $650 (v) $1,200 (d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38 (ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300 Lease Agreement $1,000 (iii) Audit Enquiry $125 (iv) Review Agreement $650 (v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200 Geraldton Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $715,618.09 (b) Altorfer & Stow Freehill Hollingdale & Page Mullins Handcock Phillips Fox (c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35 Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62 Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50 Phillips Fox - $44,607.62 (d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project). Fremantle Port Authority The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date. (a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(a) $1,575,846 (b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(b) Clayton Utz , Illbery’s , Jackson McDonald , Freehills (c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(c) Clayton Utz $1,293,081 Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Illbery’s $ 247,033 Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Jackson McDonald $ 29,153 Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Freehills $ 6,579 (d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
(d) Clayton Utz Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation Illbery’s Property including leases. Jackson McDonald Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property Freehills Industrial and employee relations Port Hedland Port Authority a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
a) $53,911.42 b) Clayton Utz Freehills Gilbert & Tobin Hunt & Humphry Minter Ellison Tottle Christensen c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91 Freehills $20,857.10 Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82 Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95 Minter Ellison $ 194.55 Tottle Christensen $ 299.09 d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
AnswerView source ↗
Answered
16 December 2003
Responded by
Minister for Planning and Infrastructure
Response time
91 days
Department of Planning and Infrastructure
[Note: The Department for Planning and Infrastructure was established on 1 July 2001 and the Department of Transport was abolished on 30 June 2002. The Ministry for Planning was abolished on 4 September 2001].
(a)
01-Feb-01 to
01-Jul-03 to
30-June-01
2001-02
2002-03
11-Dec-03
$
$
$
$
Department of Transport
267,575.11
4,063.30
N/A
N/A
Department for Planning
and Infrastructure
N/A
425,107.71
332,096.28
59,603.09
Ministry for Planning
NIL
9,461.75
N/A
N/A
WA Planning Commission
49,908.15
230,519.55
266,404.87
150,389.89
(b)-(c)
Amount stated is the total paid to the provider for the period.
Department of Transport
2000-01
Vendor Name
Amount
ALAN E SWANN
2,727.27
ALAN V RILEY & ASSOC
3,900.00
ARNS & ASSOCIATES
814.99
COMMERCIAL PROPERTY BRANCH
466.15
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH SOLICITORS
8,198.00
DEACONS
8,261.96
ERNST & YOUNG
1,550.00
FREEHILLS
12,308.30
GARTON SMITH & BARRETT
705.11
GEORGE GUIDICE LAW CHAMBERS
3,150.00
GIBSON TOVEY MILLS
224.20
HOLLINGDALES BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS
43,322.82
HOUSING & WORKS, DEPT OF
576.25
JOHN FOSTER
2,871.91
JOSHUA THOMSON
3,000.36
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
69,805.64
LAWTON GILLON
6,210.58
MALLESONS STEPHEN JAQUES
5,134.55
METWAY PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
640.00
OWEN LEGAL & CORPORATE
17,522.50
PAUL AND ASSOC P/L,MJ
22.50
PHILIP LAFFERTY
150.00
PHILLIPS FOX
26,493.09
PROPERTY SOLVE
630.00
PULLIN Q.C.,CJL
3,375.00
RECEIVABLES MGT LTD
5.00
RW READING
1,544.20
SINCLAIR KNIGHT MERZ
374.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
18,118.50
STANTON PARTNERS
19,973.98
TOTTLE CHRISTENSEN
3,824.25
WILSON,JA
300.00
WRAY & ASSOCIATES
1,374.00
Grand Total
267,575.11
WA Planning Commission
2000-01
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
30,548.15
Narelle Johnson QC
15,575.00
Pullinger Readhead Stewart
3,785.00
Grand Total
49.908.15
Department of Transport
2001-02
Vendor
Amount
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
1,568.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
1,190.00
RECEIVABLES MGT LTD
1,073.05
DRIVER ACCESS
232.25
Grand Total
4,063.30
Department for Planning and Infrastructure
2001-02
Vendor Name
Amount
ALAN V RILEY & ASSOC
12,750.00
BIRD CAMERON
2,800.00
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
494.25
BRONWYN DAVIES TAYLOR
926.66
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH SOLICITORS
83,255.50
DEACONS
1,234.72
FREEHILLS
61,392.44
GADENS LAWYERS
7,117.72
GARTON SMITH & BARRETT
210.00
HOLLINGDALES BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS
75.00
IAN W STEELE
4,000.00
JACKSON McDONALD
130,498.07
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
50,382.47
LAWTON GILLON
10,795.90
MALLESONS STEPHEN JAQUES
5,000.00
MCGEES NATIONAL PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
130.00
METWAY PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
1,012.00
MINTER ELLISON
13,538.55
OWEN LEGAL & CORPORATE
5,433.00
PHILLIPS FOX
5,880.00
RECEIVABLES MGT LTD
429.31
RW RICHARDSON
885.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
18,975.00
TECHNICAL RESOURCES
302.30
WRAY & ASSOCIATES
7,589.82
Grand Total
425,107.71
Ministry for Planning
2001-02
Vendor Name
Amount
Skea Hager & Co
751.25
Minter Ellison
8,590.50
Agriculture WA
120.00
Grand Total
9,461.75
WA Planning Commission
2001-02
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
164,016.00
Clayton Utz
16,311.05
Chis O’Neill & Assoc
4,680.00
Tim Johnston & Assoc
15,680.00
Narelle Johnson QC
22,832.50
Bedbrook Johnston
7,000.00
Grand Total
230,519.55
Department for Planning and Infrastructure
2002-03
Vendor Name
Amount
ALAN V RILEY & ASSOC
16,860.00
AMOG CONSULTING
71,588.84
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
6,449.00
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH SOLICITORS
2,792.50
DEACONS
2,717.24
DUN & BRADSTREET (AUST) P/L
112.40
ERNST & YOUNG
4,037.50
FREEHILLS
5,457.00
GADENS LAWYERS
19,831.04
IAN W STEELE
3,493.18
INDUSTRY & TECHNOLOGY - CAMS, DEPT
43,807.75
JACKSON McDONALD
44,305.26
JOHN FOSTER
5,459.09
JOSHUA THOMSON
1,488.00
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
48,116.69
KPMG
425.00
LAWTON GILLON
16,441.27
METWAY PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
352.00
OFFICE OF STATE REVENUE
316.30
PHILLIPS FOX
1,592.50
PRICEWATERHOUSE COOPERS
16,604.41
RICHARD O'SHANNASSY & CO
300.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
10,445.25
THE LAW SOC OF WA
1,754.28
TOTTLE CHRISTENSEN
3,438.28
VERBATIM REPORTERS
248.00
WILLIAMS & HUGHES
1,000.00
WRAY & ASSOCIATES
2,663.50
Grand Total
332,096.28
WA Planning Commission
2002-03
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
224,702.72
Narelle Johnson QC
13,737.50
Clayton Utz
1,831.60
Phillips Fox
8,793.87
Hardy Bowen
17,339.18
Grand Total
266,404.87
Department for Planning and Infrastructure
2003-04
Vendor Name
Amount
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
1,048.65
DEACONS
68.18
DUN & BRADSTREET (AUST) P/L
296.97
JOHN FOSTER
18,750.00
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
18,257.00
LAWTON GILLON
6,402.63
PHILLIPS FOX
3,050.00
RILEY & ASSOC,ALAN V
960.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
4,091.50
THOMSON,J
980.00
TOTTLE PARTNERS
400.01
CROWN LAW
5,298.15
Grand Total
54,304.94
WA Planning Commission
2003-04
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
85,124.07
Phillips Fox
3,645.82
R LeMiere
56,070.00
Jim Davies & Assoc
5,550.00
Grand Total
150,389.89
(d)
The above information was electronically extracted from financial records. They are stated, in aggregate, against each provider.
There are approximately 2,330 line item entries, totalling $1,795,129.70 that are coded to the accounting records as “legal services” of the respective departments. These items account for a wide range of departmental activities such as preparation of agreements, contracts, tender documents, evaluation of tenders, legal advice on breaches of agreements, contracts and debt collections. I am not prepared to allocate scarce resources in order to provide details to the Member about individual payments. However, if the Member has a question concerning any specific departmental payment for legal service, I would be pleased to consider it.
Public Transport Authority (WAGR -
19/2/01 – 30/6/03)
(a) – (d)
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided
19/2/01 – 30/6/03
Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications law, Contract
Law advice and Contract Drafting
Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health
and Safety.
Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Employment/Occupational
Health and Safety, Finance/Securities
Law.
Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court
Jaques Representation, Employment/
Occupational Health and Safety
Finance/Securities Law.
Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law
Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice
Crown Solicitor’s Office
Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property
Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services
Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation
TOTAL $1,522,603.80
Public Transport Authority (
1/7/03 – 11/12/03)
:
(a) – (d)
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided
1/7/03 – 11/12/03
Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications law, Contract
Law advice and Contract Drafting
Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Employment/Occupational
Health and Safety, Finance/Securities
Law.
Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court
Jaques Representation, Employment/
Occupational Health and Safety
Finance/Securities Law.
Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law
Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice
Crown Solicitor’s Office
Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property
Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice
Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover
TOTAL $408,867.54
Main Roads (a) – (d):
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE
Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business)
Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice)
Minter El
lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant)
R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd)
CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters)
Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of
Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts)
Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects)
TOTAL $2 620 577.83
Landcorp:
The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
Question (b) Provider
(C )Total Paid
(d) Service Provided
ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON.
$27,679
General Commercial Legal Advice
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
$21,219
General Commercial Legal Advice
C ZELESTIS
$66,220
Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs
CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS
$672
General Commercial Legal Advice
CLAYTON UTZ
$223,748
General Commercial Legal Advice
COCKS MACNISH
$2,148
General Commercial Legal Advice
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH
$1,740
General Commercial Legal Advice
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
$29,806
General Commercial Legal Advice
EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES
$709
General Commercial Legal Advice
FREEHILLS LAWYERS
$11,976
General Commercial Legal Advice
G D CROCKET & CO
$2,266
General Commercial Legal Advice
GADENS LAWYERS
$18,700
General Commercial Legal Advice
GILBERT & TOBIN
$859
General Commercial Legal Advice
HALSEY & ASSOCIATES
$1,500
General Commercial Legal Advice
HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS
$16,469
General Commercial Legal Advice
IRDI & ASSOCIATES
$2,120
General Commercial Legal Advice
JACKSON MCDONALD
$16,546
General Commercial Legal Advice
J GILMOUR
$5,912
Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs
KOTT GUNNING
$45,108
General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation
M HOWARD
$129,617
Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs
MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES
$230
General Commercial Legal Advice
MCLEODS
$80,291
General Commercial Legal Advice
MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE
$371,377
General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation
PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES
$33,021
General Commercial Legal Advice
PHILLIPS FOX
$173,613
General Commercial Legal Advice
PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART
$1,151,352
General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation
SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON
$1,549
General Commercial Legal Advice
VALENTI LAWYERS
$10,530
General Commercial Legal Advice
WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS
$9,437
General Commercial Legal Advice
Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice
$2,456,414
EPRA
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $791,429
(b) Provider
(c) Amount
(d) Service
Minter Ellison
$768,388
Land redevelopment legal issues
Allens Arthur Robinson
$ 2,496
Commercial land sale settlements
Phillip Fox
$ 710
Land resumption legal issues
Mr R. LeMiere
$ 4,200
Legal advice re court actions and claims
Lawton Gillon
$ 909
Batemans
$ 5,281
Godfrey Spowers
$ 1,853
Wayne Martin QC
$ 636
Considine Griffiths
$ 3,260
Wray Associates
$ 3,696
SRA
(a) $178,808
(b) Provider
(c) Amount
(d) Service
Minter Ellison
$168,268
Land redevelopment legal issues
Jackson McDonald
$ 10,808
Commercial land sale settlements
Land resumption legal issues
Legal advice re court actions and claims
Armadale Redevelopment Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $15,141
(b) Watts Woodhouse
(c) As Above
(d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme
Midland Redevelopment Authority
Up until 30 November 2003:
(a) $63,653.74
(b) Crown Solicitor’s Office
Jackson McDonald
Skea Nelson & Hager
Hager & Partners
Minter Ellison
Watts & Woodhouse
(c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20
Jackson McDonald $13,998.50
Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00
Hager & Partners $200.00
Minter Ellison $29,436.54
Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
(d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing
***********************
Albany
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
Name
Service
Amount
Freehills
Ordinance Claim
273,801
Lease documents
109,385
Contract documents
9,283
IR advice
322
Environmental advice
1,984
Confidentiality advice
4,285
Hardy Bowen
Environmental advice
4,688
Planning advice
1,350
PAA Advice
840
Murray Smith
Lease documents
11,203
IR advice
400
Phillips Fox
IR advice
4,587
Total
422,128
Broome Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $52,409.30
(b) i) Mullins Handcock
ii) Phillips Fox
iii) Clayton Utz
iv) Skea Hager & Co
(c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice
ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice
v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice
vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute
vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement
viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice
(d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice
ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice
ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice
x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute
xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement
xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice
Bunbury Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
a. $8,075.00
b. Malcolm McCusker QC
Mallesons Stephen Jacques
McLeods
Young & Young
c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000
Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300
McLeods - $1,275
Young & Young - $1,500
d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead
Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility
McLeods - Application of Act
Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport
Dampier Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
a) Total Spent:
$1,676,542
(b) Provider
(c)Amount $
(d) Service
Mullins Handcock
119,551
Port Facilities Agreement, leases
Wayne S Martin QC
6,682
Port Facilities Agreement
Chan Galic Barristers
3,513
Leases
Freehill Hollingdale
2,632
Employment Issues
Ilbery Barblett
3,000
Port Facilities Agreement
Malleson Stephens
1,400
Advice on Directors interest
Clayton Utz
1,537,502
Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs
Bankwest Conveyancing
2,137
Sale of DPA houses
State Revenue Dept
125
Stamping of Agreements
Esperance Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $20,541.38
(b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine
(ii) Freehills
(iii) Blakiston & Crabb
(iv) Mullins Handcock
(c) (i) $1,266.38
(ii) $17,300
(iii) $125
(iv) $650
(v) $1,200
(d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38
(ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300
Lease Agreement $1,000
(iii) Audit Enquiry $125
(iv) Review Agreement $650
(v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200
Geraldton Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $715,618.09
(b) Altorfer & Stow
Freehill Hollingdale & Page
Mullins Handcock
Phillips Fox
(c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35
Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62
Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50
Phillips Fox - $44,607.62
(d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project).
Fremantle Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $1,575,846
(b)
Clayton Utz
,
Illbery’s
,
Jackson McDonald
,
Freehills
(c)
Clayton Utz
$1,293,081
Illbery’s
$ 247,033
Jackson McDonald
$ 29,153
Freehills
$ 6,579
(d)
Clayton Utz
Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation
Illbery’s
Property including leases.
Jackson McDonald
Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property
Freehills
Industrial and employee relations
Port Hedland Port Authority
a) $53,911.42
b) Clayton Utz
Freehills
Gilbert & Tobin
Hunt & Humphry
Minter Ellison
Tottle Christensen
c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91
Freehills $20,857.10
Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82
Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95
Minter Ellison $ 194.55
Tottle Christensen $ 299.09
d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice
Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice
Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute
Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence
Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity
Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
[Note: The Department for Planning and Infrastructure was established on 1 July 2001 and the Department of Transport was abolished on 30 June 2002. The Ministry for Planning was abolished on 4 September 2001].
(a)
01-Feb-01 to
01-Jul-03 to
30-June-01
2001-02
2002-03
11-Dec-03
$
$
$
$
Department of Transport
267,575.11
4,063.30
N/A
N/A
Department for Planning
and Infrastructure
N/A
425,107.71
332,096.28
59,603.09
Ministry for Planning
NIL
9,461.75
N/A
N/A
WA Planning Commission
49,908.15
230,519.55
266,404.87
150,389.89
(b)-(c)
Amount stated is the total paid to the provider for the period.
Department of Transport
2000-01
Vendor Name
Amount
ALAN E SWANN
2,727.27
ALAN V RILEY & ASSOC
3,900.00
ARNS & ASSOCIATES
814.99
COMMERCIAL PROPERTY BRANCH
466.15
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH SOLICITORS
8,198.00
DEACONS
8,261.96
ERNST & YOUNG
1,550.00
FREEHILLS
12,308.30
GARTON SMITH & BARRETT
705.11
GEORGE GUIDICE LAW CHAMBERS
3,150.00
GIBSON TOVEY MILLS
224.20
HOLLINGDALES BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS
43,322.82
HOUSING & WORKS, DEPT OF
576.25
JOHN FOSTER
2,871.91
JOSHUA THOMSON
3,000.36
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
69,805.64
LAWTON GILLON
6,210.58
MALLESONS STEPHEN JAQUES
5,134.55
METWAY PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
640.00
OWEN LEGAL & CORPORATE
17,522.50
PAUL AND ASSOC P/L,MJ
22.50
PHILIP LAFFERTY
150.00
PHILLIPS FOX
26,493.09
PROPERTY SOLVE
630.00
PULLIN Q.C.,CJL
3,375.00
RECEIVABLES MGT LTD
5.00
RW READING
1,544.20
SINCLAIR KNIGHT MERZ
374.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
18,118.50
STANTON PARTNERS
19,973.98
TOTTLE CHRISTENSEN
3,824.25
WILSON,JA
300.00
WRAY & ASSOCIATES
1,374.00
Grand Total
267,575.11
WA Planning Commission
2000-01
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
30,548.15
Narelle Johnson QC
15,575.00
Pullinger Readhead Stewart
3,785.00
Grand Total
49.908.15
Department of Transport
2001-02
Vendor
Amount
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
1,568.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
1,190.00
RECEIVABLES MGT LTD
1,073.05
DRIVER ACCESS
232.25
Grand Total
4,063.30
Department for Planning and Infrastructure
2001-02
Vendor Name
Amount
ALAN V RILEY & ASSOC
12,750.00
BIRD CAMERON
2,800.00
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
494.25
BRONWYN DAVIES TAYLOR
926.66
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH SOLICITORS
83,255.50
DEACONS
1,234.72
FREEHILLS
61,392.44
GADENS LAWYERS
7,117.72
GARTON SMITH & BARRETT
210.00
HOLLINGDALES BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS
75.00
IAN W STEELE
4,000.00
JACKSON McDONALD
130,498.07
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
50,382.47
LAWTON GILLON
10,795.90
MALLESONS STEPHEN JAQUES
5,000.00
MCGEES NATIONAL PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
130.00
METWAY PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
1,012.00
MINTER ELLISON
13,538.55
OWEN LEGAL & CORPORATE
5,433.00
PHILLIPS FOX
5,880.00
RECEIVABLES MGT LTD
429.31
RW RICHARDSON
885.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
18,975.00
TECHNICAL RESOURCES
302.30
WRAY & ASSOCIATES
7,589.82
Grand Total
425,107.71
Ministry for Planning
2001-02
Vendor Name
Amount
Skea Hager & Co
751.25
Minter Ellison
8,590.50
Agriculture WA
120.00
Grand Total
9,461.75
WA Planning Commission
2001-02
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
164,016.00
Clayton Utz
16,311.05
Chis O’Neill & Assoc
4,680.00
Tim Johnston & Assoc
15,680.00
Narelle Johnson QC
22,832.50
Bedbrook Johnston
7,000.00
Grand Total
230,519.55
Department for Planning and Infrastructure
2002-03
Vendor Name
Amount
ALAN V RILEY & ASSOC
16,860.00
AMOG CONSULTING
71,588.84
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
6,449.00
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH SOLICITORS
2,792.50
DEACONS
2,717.24
DUN & BRADSTREET (AUST) P/L
112.40
ERNST & YOUNG
4,037.50
FREEHILLS
5,457.00
GADENS LAWYERS
19,831.04
IAN W STEELE
3,493.18
INDUSTRY & TECHNOLOGY - CAMS, DEPT
43,807.75
JACKSON McDONALD
44,305.26
JOHN FOSTER
5,459.09
JOSHUA THOMSON
1,488.00
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
48,116.69
KPMG
425.00
LAWTON GILLON
16,441.27
METWAY PROPERTY CONSULTANTS
352.00
OFFICE OF STATE REVENUE
316.30
PHILLIPS FOX
1,592.50
PRICEWATERHOUSE COOPERS
16,604.41
RICHARD O'SHANNASSY & CO
300.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
10,445.25
THE LAW SOC OF WA
1,754.28
TOTTLE CHRISTENSEN
3,438.28
VERBATIM REPORTERS
248.00
WILLIAMS & HUGHES
1,000.00
WRAY & ASSOCIATES
2,663.50
Grand Total
332,096.28
WA Planning Commission
2002-03
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
224,702.72
Narelle Johnson QC
13,737.50
Clayton Utz
1,831.60
Phillips Fox
8,793.87
Hardy Bowen
17,339.18
Grand Total
266,404.87
Department for Planning and Infrastructure
2003-04
Vendor Name
Amount
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
1,048.65
DEACONS
68.18
DUN & BRADSTREET (AUST) P/L
296.97
JOHN FOSTER
18,750.00
JUSTICE,MINISTRY OF
18,257.00
LAWTON GILLON
6,402.63
PHILLIPS FOX
3,050.00
RILEY & ASSOC,ALAN V
960.00
SKEA HAGER & CO.
4,091.50
THOMSON,J
980.00
TOTTLE PARTNERS
400.01
CROWN LAW
5,298.15
Grand Total
54,304.94
WA Planning Commission
2003-04
Vendor Name
Amount
Ministry of Justice
85,124.07
Phillips Fox
3,645.82
R LeMiere
56,070.00
Jim Davies & Assoc
5,550.00
Grand Total
150,389.89
(d)
The above information was electronically extracted from financial records. They are stated, in aggregate, against each provider.
There are approximately 2,330 line item entries, totalling $1,795,129.70 that are coded to the accounting records as “legal services” of the respective departments. These items account for a wide range of departmental activities such as preparation of agreements, contracts, tender documents, evaluation of tenders, legal advice on breaches of agreements, contracts and debt collections. I am not prepared to allocate scarce resources in order to provide details to the Member about individual payments. However, if the Member has a question concerning any specific departmental payment for legal service, I would be pleased to consider it.
Public Transport Authority (WAGR -
19/2/01 – 30/6/03)
(a) – (d)
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided
19/2/01 – 30/6/03
Tottle Christensen $ 57,752.16 Commercial property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Hollingdales $ 515,975.69 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Blake Dawson Waldron $ 63,049.46 Commercial property and leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications law, Contract
Law advice and Contract Drafting
Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Haydn Robinson $ 76,919.85 Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Phillips Fox $ 16,000.00 Employment/Occupational Health
and Safety.
Freehills $ 65,125.29 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Employment/Occupational
Health and Safety, Finance/Securities
Law.
Mallesons Stephen $ 260,143.43 Dispute Resolution/Court
Jaques Representation, Employment/
Occupational Health and Safety
Finance/Securities Law.
Jackson McDonald $ 7,700.75 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Teller and Associates $ 10,005.03 Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Deacons $ 55,178.59 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law
Department of Justice $ 233,432.40 General Legal Advice
Crown Solicitor’s Office
Minter Ellison $ 165,580.90 Commercial Property
Pye and Quartermaine $ 1,100.00 Professional Services
Mark Andrews & Assoc $ 456.00 Court Representation
TOTAL $1,522,603.80
Public Transport Authority (
1/7/03 – 11/12/03)
:
(a) – (d)
Name of Provider Amount Paid Service Provided
1/7/03 – 11/12/03
Tottle Christensen $ 6,000.16 Commercial property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Hollingdales $ 117,550.08 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Blake Dawson Waldron $ 139,760.92 Commercial property and leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications law, Contract
Law advice and Contract Drafting
Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Haydn Robinson $ 1,538.00 Dispute Resolution/Court
Representation.
Freehills $ 10,940.82 Contract Law Advice and Contract
Drafting Employment/Occupational
Health and Safety, Finance/Securities
Law.
Mallesons Stephen $ 12,888.08 Dispute Resolution/Court
Jaques Representation, Employment/
Occupational Health and Safety
Finance/Securities Law.
Jackson McDonald $ 5,372.95 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law.
Teller and Associates $ 2,941.76 Intellectual Property/Information
Technology Law.
Deacons $ 3,525.50 Commercial Property and Leasing,
Planning, Heritage,
Telecommunications Law
Department of Justice $ 95,091.28 General Legal Advice
Crown Solicitor’s Office
Minter Ellison $ 3,282.75 Commercial Property
Gadens Lawyers $ 9,023.85 Legal Advice
Lawrence and Howell $ 951.39 Insurance and Third Party Cover
TOTAL $408,867.54
Main Roads (a) – (d):
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
PROVIDER AMOUNT SERVICE
Crown Solicitor’s Office $306 017.47 Services in relation to "non-core business". (CSO does not bill for services in relation to "core" business)
Blake Dawson Waldron $1, 398, 69.66 Contract 819/98 - Provision of Legal Services (commercial and contractual matters, and general advice)
Minter El
lison $44, 046.57 Contract 665/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Graham Farmer Freeway Tunnel Land (issues relating to land title and covenant)
R Le Miere $83, 390.00 Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Duffy & Ors) and Dawesville Deviation (Aberdeen Nominees Pty Ltd)
CB Edmonds $159, 225.00 Contract 597/01 - Land compensation appeal concerning land resumed for the Graham Farmer Freeway (Arcus Shop Fitters)
Freehills $172, 833.12 Contract 973/02 - Provision of
Legal Services for Alliance Contracting Issues (Roe Highway Stage 7, and Term Network Contracts)
Hollingdales $456, 696.01 Contract 707/98 - Provision of Legal Services for Road Contracts (Major Projects)
TOTAL $2 620 577.83
Landcorp:
The following table was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
Question (b) Provider
(C )Total Paid
(d) Service Provided
ALLENS ARTHUR ROBINSON.
$27,679
General Commercial Legal Advice
BLAKE DAWSON WALDRON
$21,219
General Commercial Legal Advice
C ZELESTIS
$66,220
Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs
CLARK WHYTE PROPERTY LAWYERS
$672
General Commercial Legal Advice
CLAYTON UTZ
$223,748
General Commercial Legal Advice
COCKS MACNISH
$2,148
General Commercial Legal Advice
CORRS CHAMBERS WESTGARTH
$1,740
General Commercial Legal Advice
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
$29,806
General Commercial Legal Advice
EDWIN ABDO & ASSOCIATES
$709
General Commercial Legal Advice
FREEHILLS LAWYERS
$11,976
General Commercial Legal Advice
G D CROCKET & CO
$2,266
General Commercial Legal Advice
GADENS LAWYERS
$18,700
General Commercial Legal Advice
GILBERT & TOBIN
$859
General Commercial Legal Advice
HALSEY & ASSOCIATES
$1,500
General Commercial Legal Advice
HARDY BOWEN LAWYERS
$16,469
General Commercial Legal Advice
IRDI & ASSOCIATES
$2,120
General Commercial Legal Advice
JACKSON MCDONALD
$16,546
General Commercial Legal Advice
J GILMOUR
$5,912
Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs
KOTT GUNNING
$45,108
General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation
M HOWARD
$129,617
Senior Counsel – Litigation Costs
MALLESONS STEPHAN JAQUES
$230
General Commercial Legal Advice
MCLEODS
$80,291
General Commercial Legal Advice
MINTER ELLISON NORTHMORE HALE
$371,377
General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation
PETER YOUNG & ASSOCIATES
$33,021
General Commercial Legal Advice
PHILLIPS FOX
$173,613
General Commercial Legal Advice
PULLINGER READHEAD STEWART
$1,151,352
General Commercial Legal Advice including Litigation
SLEE ANDERSON & PIDGEON
$1,549
General Commercial Legal Advice
VALENTI LAWYERS
$10,530
General Commercial Legal Advice
WOJTOWICZ KELLY BARRISTERS & SOLICITORS
$9,437
General Commercial Legal Advice
Question (a) Total amount spent on Legal Advice
$2,456,414
EPRA
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $791,429
(b) Provider
(c) Amount
(d) Service
Minter Ellison
$768,388
Land redevelopment legal issues
Allens Arthur Robinson
$ 2,496
Commercial land sale settlements
Phillip Fox
$ 710
Land resumption legal issues
Mr R. LeMiere
$ 4,200
Legal advice re court actions and claims
Lawton Gillon
$ 909
Batemans
$ 5,281
Godfrey Spowers
$ 1,853
Wayne Martin QC
$ 636
Considine Griffiths
$ 3,260
Wray Associates
$ 3,696
SRA
(a) $178,808
(b) Provider
(c) Amount
(d) Service
Minter Ellison
$168,268
Land redevelopment legal issues
Jackson McDonald
$ 10,808
Commercial land sale settlements
Land resumption legal issues
Legal advice re court actions and claims
Armadale Redevelopment Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $15,141
(b) Watts Woodhouse
(c) As Above
(d) Legal advice for Redevelopment Scheme
Midland Redevelopment Authority
Up until 30 November 2003:
(a) $63,653.74
(b) Crown Solicitor’s Office
Jackson McDonald
Skea Nelson & Hager
Hager & Partners
Minter Ellison
Watts & Woodhouse
(c) Crowns Solicitor’s Office $13,548.20
Jackson McDonald $13,998.50
Skea Nelson & Hager $4,725.00
Hager & Partners $200.00
Minter Ellison $29,436.54
Watts & Woodhouse $1,745.50
(d) Interpretation of legislation and town planning schemes, license and lease preparations, dealings, capital works tender contract documentation review, project management process documental review, land sales tender documentation, conveyancing
***********************
Albany
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
Name
Service
Amount
Freehills
Ordinance Claim
273,801
Lease documents
109,385
Contract documents
9,283
IR advice
322
Environmental advice
1,984
Confidentiality advice
4,285
Hardy Bowen
Environmental advice
4,688
Planning advice
1,350
PAA Advice
840
Murray Smith
Lease documents
11,203
IR advice
400
Phillips Fox
IR advice
4,587
Total
422,128
Broome Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $52,409.30
(b) i) Mullins Handcock
ii) Phillips Fox
iii) Clayton Utz
iv) Skea Hager & Co
(c) i) Mullins Handcock $3,250 Shipping advice
ii) Phillips Fox $ 697 Industrial Relations Advice
v) Clayton Utz $44,078 Industrial Relations Advice
vi) Clayton Utz $ 1,942 Western Power tariff dispute
vii) Skea Hager & Co $2,112 Drafting Services Agreement
viii) Skea Hager & Co $330 Land lease advice
(d) i) Mullins Handcock Shipping advice
ii) Phillips Fox Industrial Relations Advice
ix) Clayton Utz Industrial Relations Advice
x) Clayton Utz Western Power tariff dispute
xi) Skea Hager & Co Drafting Services Agreement
xii) Skea Hager & Co Land lease advice
Bunbury Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
a. $8,075.00
b. Malcolm McCusker QC
Mallesons Stephen Jacques
McLeods
Young & Young
c. Malcolm McCusker QC - $4,000
Mallesons Stephen Jacques - $1,300
McLeods - $1,275
Young & Young - $1,500
d. Malcolm McCusker - Chip Mill & Homestead
Mallesons Stephen Jacques - Container Facility
McLeods - Application of Act
Young & Young - Wesfarmers Transport
Dampier Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
a) Total Spent:
$1,676,542
(b) Provider
(c)Amount $
(d) Service
Mullins Handcock
119,551
Port Facilities Agreement, leases
Wayne S Martin QC
6,682
Port Facilities Agreement
Chan Galic Barristers
3,513
Leases
Freehill Hollingdale
2,632
Employment Issues
Ilbery Barblett
3,000
Port Facilities Agreement
Malleson Stephens
1,400
Advice on Directors interest
Clayton Utz
1,537,502
Port Facilities Agreements, tender docs
Bankwest Conveyancing
2,137
Sale of DPA houses
State Revenue Dept
125
Stamping of Agreements
Esperance Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $20,541.38
(b) (i) Pye & Quartermaine
(ii) Freehills
(iii) Blakiston & Crabb
(iv) Mullins Handcock
(c) (i) $1,266.38
(ii) $17,300
(iii) $125
(iv) $650
(v) $1,200
(d) (i) Industrial Relations $1,266.38
(ii) Power Purchase Agreement $16,300
Lease Agreement $1,000
(iii) Audit Enquiry $125
(iv) Review Agreement $650
(v) Directors Deed of Indemnity $1,200
Geraldton Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $715,618.09
(b) Altorfer & Stow
Freehill Hollingdale & Page
Mullins Handcock
Phillips Fox
(c) Altorfer & Stow - $2,746.35
Freehill Hollingdale & Page - $563,519.62
Mullins Handcock - $104,744.50
Phillips Fox - $44,607.62
(d) Commercial Port Business Operations, particularly in relation to the Port Enhancement Project ($103 Million deepening and berth reconstruction project).
Fremantle Port Authority
The following was amended on 11 December 2003 to reflect costs incurred to that date.
(a) $1,575,846
(b)
Clayton Utz
,
Illbery’s
,
Jackson McDonald
,
Freehills
(c)
Clayton Utz
$1,293,081
Illbery’s
$ 247,033
Jackson McDonald
$ 29,153
Freehills
$ 6,579
(d)
Clayton Utz
Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial including customer and other contracts and agreements, legislative, tendering and procurements, environmental, State Agreements, industrial and employee relations, asset sales, FOI, Trade Practices, litigation, taxation
Illbery’s
Property including leases.
Jackson McDonald
Port management and operations, maritime, corporate and commercial, legislative, tendering and procurements, intellectual property
Freehills
Industrial and employee relations
Port Hedland Port Authority
a) $53,911.42
b) Clayton Utz
Freehills
Gilbert & Tobin
Hunt & Humphry
Minter Ellison
Tottle Christensen
c) Clayton Utz $ 4,630.91
Freehills $20,857.10
Gilbert & Tobin $ 581.82
Hunt & Humphry $27,347.95
Minter Ellison $ 194.55
Tottle Christensen $ 299.09
d) Clayton Utz Stevedoring Licence and Electricity Tarriff Advice
Freehills Stevedoring Licence and Work Boat Advice
Gilbert & Tobin TNT Dispute
Hunt & Humphry Native Title Advice, Pilotage Contract, Hope Downs Lease, BP Australia Licence
Minter Ellison Deeds of Indemnity
Tottle Christensen TNT Accounts Dispute
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.