❓ A WA parliamentary question addresses the potential economic impact of feeding ham to sheep and the government's stance on genetically modified crops, particularly regarding potential economic harm to grain growers. The Minister assures a cautious approach to GM crops to prevent economic harm.
AnsweredQoN 1566Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
(1) In noting that the minister has described the feeding of ham to sheep as economic sabotage, is this action likely to impact adversely on the live sheep market? (2) Does the minister describe the growing of genetically modified crops in Western Australia as economic sabotage, when the bulk of the evidence shows that contamination of our grain crops through the spread of this material would cause severe economic harm to Western Australian grain growers? Hon KIM CHANCE
AnswerView source ↗
I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
(2) Does the minister describe the growing of genetically modified crops in Western Australia as economic sabotage, when the bulk of the evidence shows that contamination of our grain crops through the spread of this material would cause severe economic harm to Western Australian grain growers? Hon KIM CHANCE replied : I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
Hon KIM CHANCE replied : I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
(1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
(2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
(2) Does the minister describe the growing of genetically modified crops in Western Australia as economic sabotage, when the bulk of the evidence shows that contamination of our grain crops through the spread of this material would cause severe economic harm to Western Australian grain growers? Hon KIM CHANCE replied : I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
Hon KIM CHANCE replied : I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
I thank the member for some notice of this question. (1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
(1) This matter has been dealt with quickly and efficiently by the relevant Australian Government and Victorian authorities. We would expect the market to adopt a cautious approach. I am not able to judge whether there will be an economic impact on the live sheep trade at this point, although that was clearly the offender’s intention. (2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
(2) No. I do not describe any legal act as sabotage. As the member knows, the Government is taking a cautious approach to the issue of genetically modified crops, and possible economic consequences will always be a part of any consideration of the matter. The very reason for the Gallop Government’s actions to control the entry of GM crops into Western Australia agriculture is based on the need to ensure that no such economic harm can occur, and that is something that I hope the member supports.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.