❓ Hon Helen Morton questions the Minister for Health regarding the transfer of an at-risk patient from Swan District Hospital to Bentley Hospital, focusing on the appropriateness of the transfer method and subsequent lack of policy changes. The response was delayed.
AnsweredQoN 490Legislative Council
QuestionView source ↗
AT-RISK PATIENT - TRANSFER
I refer to the situation in which a man was assessed in the emergency department of Swan District Hospital on 9 January as being at risk of harm to himself and others but had to be transferred to Bentley Hospital and jumped out of a taxi en route. (1) Why could the man not be admitted to the Swan District Hospital given that he was assessed as being at risk to himself and others? (2) Why was it not considered preferable that the transfer be undertaken by ambulance or with a mental health worker escort? (3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST
I refer to the situation in which a man was assessed in the emergency department of Swan District Hospital on 9 January as being at risk of harm to himself and others but had to be transferred to Bentley Hospital and jumped out of a taxi en route. (1) Why could the man not be admitted to the Swan District Hospital given that he was assessed as being at risk to himself and others? (2) Why was it not considered preferable that the transfer be undertaken by ambulance or with a mental health worker escort? (3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST
AnswerView source ↗
On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(1) Why could the man not be admitted to the Swan District Hospital given that he was assessed as being at risk to himself and others? (2) Why was it not considered preferable that the transfer be undertaken by ambulance or with a mental health worker escort? (3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(2) Why was it not considered preferable that the transfer be undertaken by ambulance or with a mental health worker escort? (3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(1) Why could the man not be admitted to the Swan District Hospital given that he was assessed as being at risk to himself and others? (2) Why was it not considered preferable that the transfer be undertaken by ambulance or with a mental health worker escort? (3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(2) Why was it not considered preferable that the transfer be undertaken by ambulance or with a mental health worker escort? (3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(3) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the decision to transfer the patient and the means of transport? (4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(4) If no, who is deemed responsible? (5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(5) Will the minister, as the Metropolitan Health Service Board, accept responsibility for the consequences of the decision? (6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(6) If no, who is deemed responsible for the consequences of the decision? (7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
(7) What policy changes have taken place to ensure that a situation such as this never happens again? Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
Hon KATE DOUST replied: On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
On behalf of the parliamentary secretary representing the Minister for Health, unfortunately I do not have a response for that question at this time. Hopefully it will arrive before the end of question time.
Explore WA Government Data
Search the full archive in the free dashboard, or query programmatically via API.
Explore more
Government Gazette
Appointments, regulatory notices, planning changes.
Hansard
Debates, questions, speeches and sentiment.
Tabled Papers
Reports and documents tabled in Parliament.
Committees
Committee profiles and recent reports.
Regulations
Subsidiary legislation with filters and summaries.
Bills
Proposed laws and parliamentary progress.
Acts
Current WA legislation and summaries.
Explanatory Memoranda
Bills with EMs (text/PDF) available.
Members
MP profiles, party breakdown and rankings.
Pollie Rankings
Data-driven rankings across 19 categories.
Amendment Chains
Track how schemes and regulations evolve over time.